Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Robert Moskowitz's avatar

I don't understand why risk are reward are treated as though they must all be given to one side or the other. In reality, it takes both the owners and the workers to make a successful business. The contributions of both are valuable, and deserve full compensation. Hence, the rewards of success ought to be split more equitably than they are today in most cases. I'm OK with Jeff Bezos making millions, but does he need billions while his workers make on the order of $50K / year? Couldn't he make do with one billion? or five billion? Corporate charters are controlled by laws, and those laws could mandate that profits and ownership be split among workers and owners according to some equitable formula, which could be tweaked as experience indicates. Hey, workers could even be included among the owners, automatically, as a matter of law. Is that so wrong?

Expand full comment
Jo Candiano's avatar

I am a business owner and this is legit. The risk is having to become a worker. But... I am always "on". There is no "vacation" without work. I have had plenty of holidays over the years, and have worked during all of them. The potential for legal action goes up when you own a business. PayPal can lock your funds. Staff hide in the warehouse to check phones all day. They make mistakes and send customers the wrong item. You get yelled at by customers and staff. You have a nervous breakdown or two because sales are down. There's a pandemic and you have to stop trading. There's not knowing how much you'll earn from one day to the next. You have no retirement savings because you have to sell the business to make money (if it sells). If you get bored, you can't just "change jobs". There is more to risk than you're letting on. I am a progressive socialist. I grew up with a communist father who was a farmer, and at a time and place when communism was about worker's rights not despotism. Anyway, I just wanted to remind you that this argument is far more nuanced.

Expand full comment
13 more comments...

No posts