Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Chevanne Scordinsky's avatar

I hate paying for something just to use the bathroom. I would rather fish for change then buy a coffee I don’t want.

I think the government could operate these services successfully but in a previous post, you highlighted hostile architecture, which I think plays a part. We do not adequately care for citizens and adopt exclusionary practices to keep certain people out. The public ends up in legion with these practices because they can afford to be included. Coffee for a wee seems like a good deal. No benches, no houseless people. Good deal.

We also don’t like “free” things in our society either. We get obsessed counting who contributes without accepting it’s for the greater good. People steal, take advantage, and lie. They will. How do we build better despite this?

Expand full comment
NotEnough's avatar

I think this comes down to the debate of whether institutions are more effectively run by the government or by private institutions / businesses. Theoretically this is a decent idea, but I can’t imagine it working in practice.

I’d personally rather give my money to Starbucks in exchange for a bathroom cleaner than what is readily available on the outskirts of a public park. I’d rather spend money at a private business that, in return, gives me consistent, quality service (clean-ish bathrooms and tasty coffee) than pay taxes that are then used by a state that has repeatedly proven to be ineffective with budgeting, allocation of spend, and achieving effective outcomes.

Plus, even if we do find a way to build these structures with our existing budget, what would prevent them from being usurped by homeless people as free, warm shelters? I imagine these places would smell pretty badly, and get dirty within days. Who would be motivated to maintain a high standard of hygiene? Would we then need to develop a new state-run program to run health checks on these free-for-all bathrooms and shelters? And then where would that money come from?

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts