Prominent leftist podcasters funded by Central Intelligence Agency assets (and a few others desperate to make a buck) really want you to love far-right Republicans and hate progressive Democrats.
I have to admit I'm biased because I've been a Bad Faith listener since I started getting into podcasts in 2020, and I have a parasocial relationship to BJG (hey, at least I can own up to my parasocial relationships with podcasters and public figures). I wholeheartedly agree with your criticism of Cenk Uygur —a union busting CEO who buddied up to Charlie Kirk in an ill-fated attempt at being a populist— and Ana Kasparian —perhaps one of the greatest examples of the white liberal type condemned by MLK and Malcolm X—, but I genuinely don't think that BJG fits in the same basket as them.
I know she tends to be a problematic and polarizing figure for many people. I certainly don't agree with everything she says or does, and I can't stand some of the people she is close to (Butch Ware and Glenn Greenwald are the first to come to mind), but I honestly think she does a very good job at interviewing people on her show and fostering actual dialogue and debate among leftists. I would also argue that the point she and Sana Saeed made in their conversation wasn't that people should in any way support a far-right bigoted nut job like MTG, but that it's a pretty bad look for any progressive to be out flanked from the left (even if for all the wrong reasons) by said nut job when it comes to anti-Zionist and anti-interventionist positions. And I think we can agree that the Overton window in the US still needs a massive leftward shift when it comes to Palestine, especially from so-called "representatives."
I'd also like to add that BJG was fired from a cushy job at The Hill for her reporting on the Palestinian genocide and for holding very principled anti-Zionist views. Much like Brie, I was a huge AOC supporter when she first got into Congress, but was disgusted when she got up on that DNC stage and said Kamala Harris was working tirelessly for a ceasefire in Gaza, which was deeply hurtful and insulting for everyone protesting the genocide, not to mention the very people being subjected to it. And I get the pragmatic and urgent necessity of beating Trump, but it was precisely the Democratic establishment's refusal to move even an inch to the left that gave him the White House, again.
Anyway, sorry for the long unhinged rant. I still value your writing and perspective and will continue reading what you have to say.
I get that about BJG, but the constant whitewashing of far-right Republicans, including in this episode, when she felt the need to say the media "lost credibility" by calling Trump's 2016 escalator speech racist. Combine that with her having financial support from Peter Thiel, and the echoes of Cold War wrecking, and I can't ignore it.
if you listen to the context in which she spoke that, she finished up the point by saying that the media lost credibility because they said *that* comment was racist but chose NOT to focus on other instances in which Trump had been quite bigoted, such as when he discriminated against Black tenants. She said the media needed to get more sophisticated in critiquing right-wingers like Trump and Tucker. She also pointed out that "not sending their best" *could* be construed as a statement more about class (obvs the people walking or swimming across the border are poor, it's not the wealthy who are doing this), which is how *some* people could have construed it (she emphasized that those were not her values but she can see how it could be interpreted that way). People can disagree with her analysis! But I would say that to call her analysis "whitewashing" of Trump is a pretty big stretch.
People don't call Trump's 2016 escalator speech racist because he said "they're not sending their best." They do because he said Mexicans were rapists. The lie "scary brown men are coming to rape our white women" has been the go-to line for every genocide, including the multiple ones carried out by the American government.
Thank you for finally giving me the receipts I needed to stop defending BJG against the people I thought were fed-jacketing her. Taking money from Thiel and Sacks is beyond the pale. Solid article!
Very late to the conversation, but this line doesn't match what I'm actually hearing from people making the unflattering AOC vs MTG/Tucker comparison: "constant whitewashing of far-right Republicans".
I hear a lot of people in my circles say that MTG and Tucker are outflanking AOC, doing a better job on key issues. That's never a statement meant to praise MTG or Tucker. Everyone making these comparisons, including me, detests MTG and considers Tucker Carlson scum of the Earth. Instead, it's a statement of horror that our party's standards have fallen so low that disgusting monsters like MTG are showing (or at least performing) more courage and morality than even AOC, who for a while looked like our party's brightest star. It's a statement of despair that people who in the bottom .1% of the human species, like MTG and Tucker, are outflanking us on fundamental beliefs. It's a statement of how lost we are as a party right now.
That may be what you're saying. But BJG is explicitly whitewashing Greene. During the episode, her guest said, "Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez carried more water for the genocide of Palestinians than Marjorie Taylor Greene ever did.” Gray agreed "100%", clipped the statement, and put it on Instagram.
For this to be true, we have to ignore the genocidal rhetoric MTG used to dehumanize Palestinians and American anti-genocide protestors in the weeks after 10/7. That was the moment in which the genocidal narrative was being set, which is why Zionists were spreading warmongering lies.
I don't mind if people criticize AOC. But they are explicitly whitewashing MTG's record (which should put her in the Hague).
I actually have to agree with this statement: "Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez carried more water for the genocide of Palestinians than Marjorie Taylor Greene ever did.”
MTG has obviously said far more reprehensible things about Palestinians and Arabs in general over her life. But she's a known fringe weirdo racist and she didn't go out of her way at all to continue being a racist. She's not capable of carrying very much water even if she tries. She has no legitimate voice here and could barely carry a leaky thimble full of water.
AOC, by contrast, was a trusted voice of morality on precisely things like this. And she used that voice to betray all of her principles and go full Goebbels for the Biden administration. She rallied behind him, encouraging him to stay in the race--which was indefensible both strategically and morally. And she outright lied that there were meaningful efforts ongoing to secure a ceasefire, when we've since learned that the entire Biden administration couldn't have cared less. AOC carried massive buckets of water here compared to MTG, not because what she said was objectively worse in isolation. But because her position gave her much more leverage to carry that water. Her lickspittle actions here mattered far more than MTG's and are a much more vile display of genocide-apologist sycophancy.
Again, I view this not as a "MTG record good" statement in any way, and I don't think it whitewashes her record at all. It's more like: "my god, AOC, what are you doing?!?!"
MTG is racist scum, but that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t criticize AOC or Bernie when they peddle a softer-sounding liberal zionism and center Israeli safety in the midst of Israelis commiting genocide. I’m glad she’s been moved on this issue (due to said criticism), but she has to prove it
I can accept saying AOC isn’t a liberal-Zionist, but to call Bernie Sanders anything other than a liberal (or “labor”) Zionist is simply untrue. He wholeheartedly defends the existence of Israel as a Jewish ethnostate. How long did it take him to even call the genocide a genocide?
I overall really appreciated this article as someone who used to listen to BJG’s commentary. She is absolutely an opportunist and careerist before anything else.
She was also one of the few left-media types to platform Kshama Sawant and Socialist Alternative when we were defending our council seat against a right-wing billionaire-funded recall campaign that attacked her for participating in the 2020 BLM protests.
I don’t always agree with your takes, but this was balanced and measured IMO. And absolutely fuck the Young Turks. We gotta stop worshipping media talking heads just like we need to stop worshipping politicians.
“While the Communist Party USA was working to build the New Deal as a much-needed antidote to fascism, the Trotskyists spent their time writing articles (the 1930s version of a podcast) relentlessly attacking them as “fascists,” “reformists,” and “sell-outs.” (Sound familiar?)
What a gross oversimplification of the period. How did the 1934 General Strike of Minneapolis happen? If Trotskyists were nothing more than 1930s “podcasters,” how were they able to win such a monumental strike?
I’m extremely open to hearing criticism of Trotskyism/Trotskyists, and I have plenty of my own as a Trotskyist myself, but this is lazy. I genuinely think you’re a better writer than that, and I at least thought your politics were better than that.
Right. The post then launched into a long, obsessive Trotsky smear screed. There's where I stopped reading. False advertising! Could we please stop rehashing a DEAD past, as dead as Stalin and the Soviet Union?
Otherwise history shows that the CPUSA were FDRs useful idiots, helping to build the New Deal's military industrial complex (MIC) that was then deployed against the Soviet Union, China, and the decolonizing world after WW2. Anyone who thinks the USA entered WW2 "to fight Fascism" needs to explain what happened after the war. Meanwhile during the war the CPUSA were the most ardent supporters of the CIO No Strike pledge, opposing the many wildcat strikes during that war and alienating themselves from the most militant union workers. That, among other factors not mentioned here, made the CPUSA easy pickings for the McCarthy purges.
Of course they are. They both have been vocal in their beliefs that Israel should exist as a state. That is a Zionist position. They’re not advocating for decolonization.
I think "Americans had the most trust in the mass media in 1976, following principled, critical coverage of Watergate and the Vietnam War" is a bit simplified: As detailed in Manufacturing Consent, mainstream media was not, in fact, doing much principled critical coverage of at least the Vietnam War until well after it wouldve been useful to the average viewer. Support for the war was positively correlated with hours of TV viewing, for instance.
I could have worded that better. The coverage wasn't ideal, but the press's images of war did help turn public opinion against it. And I do believe Americans saw that as principled.
Some interesting points and facts in this piece, Joe! Definitely thought-provoking. Some of the logic is kind of twisty and it ultimately seems to uphold the duopoly.
I agree about the right-wing personalities mentioned. Not convinced Briahna Joy Gray is compromised based on this information, but questioning motives and exploring connections is good in our situation.
An excellent resource on these matters is “Who Paid the Pipers of Western Marxism” by @Gabriel Rockhill. I will check out the book you mentioned as well!
The left knows the CIA is destroying the left. The right also believes the CIA is interfering in their politics, whatever they are, and they’re probably right. The left and a good portion of the right are done with the terrorist colony of Israel. There are a lot of things we should be able to come together on and take care of.
I’d like to hear you flesh out the claims you make of American Trotskyism in the 20th century. You say a lot in a couple paragraphs that oversimplifies and ignores a lot of historical context.
I’d also be curious if you do have any critiques of the CPUSA in the same time period. If I read this article having been relatively unfamiliar with Trotskyism and Stalinism, I could assume you are fully aligned with the CPUSA of the 20th century.
I also think it’s a big stretch to lump in modern day political parties, like Socialist Alternative, with the left-podcast sphere. We wholeheartedly supported Force the Vote, and we also have MANY disagreements with folks like Jimmy Dore, and BJG for that matter. Kshama Sawant was a *Trotskyist* in Seattle City Council for 10 years (2014-2024), being elected to office before the DSA and Bernie’s meteoric rise.
I also have my critiques of Sawant! I even have critiques of my own party! But I would much rather you argue these points more clearly, and not just include them as footnotes in an article about lefty podcasters.
I have many critiques of CPUSA, and pretty much any leftist organization that's ever existed. But I do believe supporting the New Deal was the correct move. And you're also correct, this is a simplified version of 20th-century Trotskyism. I wasn't trying to share my full views, only draw a parallel between the Trots who went on to support Republicans and what's happening today.
I don't believe I mentioned SA, so I certainly wasn't trying to lump them in with BJG.
But once again, I want to reiterate how much I appreciate you responding in good faith. I wish more of the left ecosystem was willing to engage in good faith debate.
I guess I meant it as in you lumped all the FTV people together as just lefty podcasters, which isn’t the whole truth. My point was that there were genuine organizers who do real tangible work who supported that initiative.
With respect, you didn’t fulfill your important promise to me as a consumer of content. I wanted answers to his direct questions! See here for someone else making the same point:
1. Why are you giving a podcast named after genocidaires by a bunch of talking heads whose most recent significant activity was “why I left the left” grifting the fig leaf of calling them leftist/left-leaning?
2. I feel like the phrase “personal vendettas against the Soviet Union” is both an understatement and dancing kinda close to the flame of Soviet apologia. Of course, I freely admit that I’m a little bit hypervigilant for the ol’ “US Bad -> Soviet Union Good -> Russia Good -> Putin Good” pipeline that a lot of nominal leftists fell down when Putin invaded Ukraine.
I'm not saying there weren't some valid critiques of the USSR, especially during Stalinism. I'm pointing out that some ultra-leftists let their personal feelings against other leftists drive them into neoconservatism. Because that did happen.
Great to see someone connect the dots around these absurd takes from podcast people. This, too: “Too often, American audiences let mainstream media talking heads with no connection to actual political movements dictate what those movements should do.” It describes so much NYT involvement in politics in particular. It’s how they end up endorsing people like Amy Klobuchar for president, who didn’t come anywhere near winning her own state primary. Or sending columnists like Frank Bruni on TV the morning after the 2016 election to say Dems lost because they were too far left on “boutique issues” like trans rights (https://fair.org/home/nyt-protects-its-pundit-who-dismissed-trans-rights-as-boutique-issue/). That people like him are invited on TV to do political analysis, when he seems to have only shifted from being a restaurant critic to writing political commentary because he developed gout, is absurd.
"Valorizing himself and his co-host Ana Kasparian for 'taking a chance' (by which he means they said things on their podcast), Cenk...." I must say, that one made me do a Christoph Waltz, "Ooh, that's a bingo!"
When did Butch Ware attack PSL? He called out DSA-LA for endorsing a billionaire who apparently made part of his fortune in for-profit prisons. But what (if anything) did he do to PSL?
The video is in here. Butch claimed Peace & Freedom revoked a promise of a gubernatorial position on the left unity slate. And "PSL only gets motion on tik tok."
Jesus Christ is this long. And boring. And incredibly selective of the facts. And filtered through the prism of "What Joe believes".
And in the end a truly bad faith argument which reveals the eternal downfall of "the Left" (wrongfully expanded to include liberals): taking a narrow and unnuanced position on everything and attacking anyone who doesn't hew precisely to that position.
It doesn't even engage honestly with the many reasons BJG and many others are disappointed with AOC. Ugh.
I dunno if you’ve bothered listening to what Briahna Joy Gray actually says about this, but I think she’s generally been pretty careful (at least when the format affords long-form explanations) about *not* uncritically praising MTG or Tucker Carlson. Her position — the *correct* position as far as I’m concerned — is simply that MTG happens to be doing and saying better on this one issue, right now, than many Democrats including AOC, and that what that should tell us is there’s a wide open lane available for Democrats to run in, AOC and the rest are just choosing not to.
I can’t say I strongly disagree or see that statement as evidence of malice, derailment, or CIA ops. Telling AOC’s audience (presumably, mostly anti-war and left-leaning people) to support Harris with such a blatant lie is indeed “carrying water” — a *LOT* of water — for an administration that enabled and in many ways actively supported genocide. At a time when, arguably, there *was* still time to convene an abbreviated convention and nominate literally anyone else who’d have had a better chance of beating Trump. A Macy’s Parade float, for instance. It’s difficult to think of a specific example of something MTG did at that level of visibility, at such a critical moment, that did that degree of harm to the cause.
This also still isn’t praise for MTG. It’s very, very sharp criticism for AOC, in that she really should have just *not* said that, but nowhere in that clip does Gray or her guest say that people should go out and support Republicans.
In that same conversation she actually brings up Stephen A. Smith’s remark about getting Black Americans to vote Republican so the Democrats might someday lift a single finger to get them back in the voting base. In order to point out that *under no circumstances* should anybody be voting for Republicans.
The 2024 DNC had no impact on the US government's policy on Palestine. It was either Kamala Harris or Trump. "Carrying water" means supporting. The best time for the left to save Palestinian lives was in October 2023. That was when Zionists were trying to set the media narrative that Palestinians weren't humans.
AOC, Rashida Tlaib, Ilhan Omar, and a few other left-wing politicians tried to stop that by calling for a ceasefire. Marjorie Taylor Greene helped the Zionists by spreading their genocidal propaganda in the US. She specifically began the campaign to call protestors "Hamas" by censoring Tlaib with extremely racist language.
I understand some people felt betrayed by AOC's line. I'm not trying to invalidate their feelings or even change their mind. By pretending that it had more influence on US policy toward Israel than the dehumanization in 2023, which Marjorie Taylor Greene should be tried for along with every other propagandist, is absurd. And it's 100% whitewashing what Greene did.
I’ll concede, for now, that it was probably effectively impossible to get a third party’s nominee into the White House. (This is because everyone always argues it’s impossible, so everyone considers them “unelectable,” which makes it impossible. But fine.)
There was, however, still plenty of time left for the DNC to choose somebody else. Harris was a really terrible choice, there’s no way around that.
I have to admit I'm biased because I've been a Bad Faith listener since I started getting into podcasts in 2020, and I have a parasocial relationship to BJG (hey, at least I can own up to my parasocial relationships with podcasters and public figures). I wholeheartedly agree with your criticism of Cenk Uygur —a union busting CEO who buddied up to Charlie Kirk in an ill-fated attempt at being a populist— and Ana Kasparian —perhaps one of the greatest examples of the white liberal type condemned by MLK and Malcolm X—, but I genuinely don't think that BJG fits in the same basket as them.
I know she tends to be a problematic and polarizing figure for many people. I certainly don't agree with everything she says or does, and I can't stand some of the people she is close to (Butch Ware and Glenn Greenwald are the first to come to mind), but I honestly think she does a very good job at interviewing people on her show and fostering actual dialogue and debate among leftists. I would also argue that the point she and Sana Saeed made in their conversation wasn't that people should in any way support a far-right bigoted nut job like MTG, but that it's a pretty bad look for any progressive to be out flanked from the left (even if for all the wrong reasons) by said nut job when it comes to anti-Zionist and anti-interventionist positions. And I think we can agree that the Overton window in the US still needs a massive leftward shift when it comes to Palestine, especially from so-called "representatives."
I'd also like to add that BJG was fired from a cushy job at The Hill for her reporting on the Palestinian genocide and for holding very principled anti-Zionist views. Much like Brie, I was a huge AOC supporter when she first got into Congress, but was disgusted when she got up on that DNC stage and said Kamala Harris was working tirelessly for a ceasefire in Gaza, which was deeply hurtful and insulting for everyone protesting the genocide, not to mention the very people being subjected to it. And I get the pragmatic and urgent necessity of beating Trump, but it was precisely the Democratic establishment's refusal to move even an inch to the left that gave him the White House, again.
Anyway, sorry for the long unhinged rant. I still value your writing and perspective and will continue reading what you have to say.
Thanks for reading!
I get that about BJG, but the constant whitewashing of far-right Republicans, including in this episode, when she felt the need to say the media "lost credibility" by calling Trump's 2016 escalator speech racist. Combine that with her having financial support from Peter Thiel, and the echoes of Cold War wrecking, and I can't ignore it.
if you listen to the context in which she spoke that, she finished up the point by saying that the media lost credibility because they said *that* comment was racist but chose NOT to focus on other instances in which Trump had been quite bigoted, such as when he discriminated against Black tenants. She said the media needed to get more sophisticated in critiquing right-wingers like Trump and Tucker. She also pointed out that "not sending their best" *could* be construed as a statement more about class (obvs the people walking or swimming across the border are poor, it's not the wealthy who are doing this), which is how *some* people could have construed it (she emphasized that those were not her values but she can see how it could be interpreted that way). People can disagree with her analysis! But I would say that to call her analysis "whitewashing" of Trump is a pretty big stretch.
People don't call Trump's 2016 escalator speech racist because he said "they're not sending their best." They do because he said Mexicans were rapists. The lie "scary brown men are coming to rape our white women" has been the go-to line for every genocide, including the multiple ones carried out by the American government.
This is whitewashing.
Thank you for finally giving me the receipts I needed to stop defending BJG against the people I thought were fed-jacketing her. Taking money from Thiel and Sacks is beyond the pale. Solid article!
Very late to the conversation, but this line doesn't match what I'm actually hearing from people making the unflattering AOC vs MTG/Tucker comparison: "constant whitewashing of far-right Republicans".
I hear a lot of people in my circles say that MTG and Tucker are outflanking AOC, doing a better job on key issues. That's never a statement meant to praise MTG or Tucker. Everyone making these comparisons, including me, detests MTG and considers Tucker Carlson scum of the Earth. Instead, it's a statement of horror that our party's standards have fallen so low that disgusting monsters like MTG are showing (or at least performing) more courage and morality than even AOC, who for a while looked like our party's brightest star. It's a statement of despair that people who in the bottom .1% of the human species, like MTG and Tucker, are outflanking us on fundamental beliefs. It's a statement of how lost we are as a party right now.
That may be what you're saying. But BJG is explicitly whitewashing Greene. During the episode, her guest said, "Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez carried more water for the genocide of Palestinians than Marjorie Taylor Greene ever did.” Gray agreed "100%", clipped the statement, and put it on Instagram.
For this to be true, we have to ignore the genocidal rhetoric MTG used to dehumanize Palestinians and American anti-genocide protestors in the weeks after 10/7. That was the moment in which the genocidal narrative was being set, which is why Zionists were spreading warmongering lies.
I don't mind if people criticize AOC. But they are explicitly whitewashing MTG's record (which should put her in the Hague).
https://www.instagram.com/p/DYfrj3RJFlR/
I actually have to agree with this statement: "Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez carried more water for the genocide of Palestinians than Marjorie Taylor Greene ever did.”
MTG has obviously said far more reprehensible things about Palestinians and Arabs in general over her life. But she's a known fringe weirdo racist and she didn't go out of her way at all to continue being a racist. She's not capable of carrying very much water even if she tries. She has no legitimate voice here and could barely carry a leaky thimble full of water.
AOC, by contrast, was a trusted voice of morality on precisely things like this. And she used that voice to betray all of her principles and go full Goebbels for the Biden administration. She rallied behind him, encouraging him to stay in the race--which was indefensible both strategically and morally. And she outright lied that there were meaningful efforts ongoing to secure a ceasefire, when we've since learned that the entire Biden administration couldn't have cared less. AOC carried massive buckets of water here compared to MTG, not because what she said was objectively worse in isolation. But because her position gave her much more leverage to carry that water. Her lickspittle actions here mattered far more than MTG's and are a much more vile display of genocide-apologist sycophancy.
Again, I view this not as a "MTG record good" statement in any way, and I don't think it whitewashes her record at all. It's more like: "my god, AOC, what are you doing?!?!"
MTG is racist scum, but that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t criticize AOC or Bernie when they peddle a softer-sounding liberal zionism and center Israeli safety in the midst of Israelis commiting genocide. I’m glad she’s been moved on this issue (due to said criticism), but she has to prove it
I don't think they're liberal zionists. But I do agree criticism is absolutely fair.
I can accept saying AOC isn’t a liberal-Zionist, but to call Bernie Sanders anything other than a liberal (or “labor”) Zionist is simply untrue. He wholeheartedly defends the existence of Israel as a Jewish ethnostate. How long did it take him to even call the genocide a genocide?
I overall really appreciated this article as someone who used to listen to BJG’s commentary. She is absolutely an opportunist and careerist before anything else.
She was also one of the few left-media types to platform Kshama Sawant and Socialist Alternative when we were defending our council seat against a right-wing billionaire-funded recall campaign that attacked her for participating in the 2020 BLM protests.
I don’t always agree with your takes, but this was balanced and measured IMO. And absolutely fuck the Young Turks. We gotta stop worshipping media talking heads just like we need to stop worshipping politicians.
Ah just got to this part:
“While the Communist Party USA was working to build the New Deal as a much-needed antidote to fascism, the Trotskyists spent their time writing articles (the 1930s version of a podcast) relentlessly attacking them as “fascists,” “reformists,” and “sell-outs.” (Sound familiar?)
What a gross oversimplification of the period. How did the 1934 General Strike of Minneapolis happen? If Trotskyists were nothing more than 1930s “podcasters,” how were they able to win such a monumental strike?
I’m extremely open to hearing criticism of Trotskyism/Trotskyists, and I have plenty of my own as a Trotskyist myself, but this is lazy. I genuinely think you’re a better writer than that, and I at least thought your politics were better than that.
Right. The post then launched into a long, obsessive Trotsky smear screed. There's where I stopped reading. False advertising! Could we please stop rehashing a DEAD past, as dead as Stalin and the Soviet Union?
Otherwise history shows that the CPUSA were FDRs useful idiots, helping to build the New Deal's military industrial complex (MIC) that was then deployed against the Soviet Union, China, and the decolonizing world after WW2. Anyone who thinks the USA entered WW2 "to fight Fascism" needs to explain what happened after the war. Meanwhile during the war the CPUSA were the most ardent supporters of the CIO No Strike pledge, opposing the many wildcat strikes during that war and alienating themselves from the most militant union workers. That, among other factors not mentioned here, made the CPUSA easy pickings for the McCarthy purges.
All in all, "good work"!
Of course they are. They both have been vocal in their beliefs that Israel should exist as a state. That is a Zionist position. They’re not advocating for decolonization.
I think "Americans had the most trust in the mass media in 1976, following principled, critical coverage of Watergate and the Vietnam War" is a bit simplified: As detailed in Manufacturing Consent, mainstream media was not, in fact, doing much principled critical coverage of at least the Vietnam War until well after it wouldve been useful to the average viewer. Support for the war was positively correlated with hours of TV viewing, for instance.
I could have worded that better. The coverage wasn't ideal, but the press's images of war did help turn public opinion against it. And I do believe Americans saw that as principled.
Yeah, it's a necessary simplification for the larger point, just thought it worth noting.
They don’t call it television “programming” for nothing.
Some interesting points and facts in this piece, Joe! Definitely thought-provoking. Some of the logic is kind of twisty and it ultimately seems to uphold the duopoly.
I agree about the right-wing personalities mentioned. Not convinced Briahna Joy Gray is compromised based on this information, but questioning motives and exploring connections is good in our situation.
An excellent resource on these matters is “Who Paid the Pipers of Western Marxism” by @Gabriel Rockhill. I will check out the book you mentioned as well!
The left knows the CIA is destroying the left. The right also believes the CIA is interfering in their politics, whatever they are, and they’re probably right. The left and a good portion of the right are done with the terrorist colony of Israel. There are a lot of things we should be able to come together on and take care of.
TY for sharing your thoughts and findings! 🕊️
Thank you for reading, and engaging in good faith!
I’d like to hear you flesh out the claims you make of American Trotskyism in the 20th century. You say a lot in a couple paragraphs that oversimplifies and ignores a lot of historical context.
I’d also be curious if you do have any critiques of the CPUSA in the same time period. If I read this article having been relatively unfamiliar with Trotskyism and Stalinism, I could assume you are fully aligned with the CPUSA of the 20th century.
I also think it’s a big stretch to lump in modern day political parties, like Socialist Alternative, with the left-podcast sphere. We wholeheartedly supported Force the Vote, and we also have MANY disagreements with folks like Jimmy Dore, and BJG for that matter. Kshama Sawant was a *Trotskyist* in Seattle City Council for 10 years (2014-2024), being elected to office before the DSA and Bernie’s meteoric rise.
I also have my critiques of Sawant! I even have critiques of my own party! But I would much rather you argue these points more clearly, and not just include them as footnotes in an article about lefty podcasters.
I have many critiques of CPUSA, and pretty much any leftist organization that's ever existed. But I do believe supporting the New Deal was the correct move. And you're also correct, this is a simplified version of 20th-century Trotskyism. I wasn't trying to share my full views, only draw a parallel between the Trots who went on to support Republicans and what's happening today.
I don't believe I mentioned SA, so I certainly wasn't trying to lump them in with BJG.
But once again, I want to reiterate how much I appreciate you responding in good faith. I wish more of the left ecosystem was willing to engage in good faith debate.
Thanks! You as well.
I guess I meant it as in you lumped all the FTV people together as just lefty podcasters, which isn’t the whole truth. My point was that there were genuine organizers who do real tangible work who supported that initiative.
This response by Glenn Greenwald seems very devastating: https://x.com/ggreenwald/status/2056854771428913633
I hope that you reply to his direct questions!
Will do!
As a consumer of content, this is what I love to hear.
I'll never deprive the internet of content.
With respect, you didn’t fulfill your important promise to me as a consumer of content. I wanted answers to his direct questions! See here for someone else making the same point:
https://x.com/ggreenwald/status/2057105784102699274
1. Why are you giving a podcast named after genocidaires by a bunch of talking heads whose most recent significant activity was “why I left the left” grifting the fig leaf of calling them leftist/left-leaning?
2. I feel like the phrase “personal vendettas against the Soviet Union” is both an understatement and dancing kinda close to the flame of Soviet apologia. Of course, I freely admit that I’m a little bit hypervigilant for the ol’ “US Bad -> Soviet Union Good -> Russia Good -> Putin Good” pipeline that a lot of nominal leftists fell down when Putin invaded Ukraine.
I'm not saying there weren't some valid critiques of the USSR, especially during Stalinism. I'm pointing out that some ultra-leftists let their personal feelings against other leftists drive them into neoconservatism. Because that did happen.
I also agree that the leftist praise for Russia is silly. Putin and Yeltsin did what the CIA could never do — end the Soviet Union.
I’ve always personally laid most of the blame at Gorbachev’s feet for introducing unemployment without also introducing some sort of UBI.
Great to see someone connect the dots around these absurd takes from podcast people. This, too: “Too often, American audiences let mainstream media talking heads with no connection to actual political movements dictate what those movements should do.” It describes so much NYT involvement in politics in particular. It’s how they end up endorsing people like Amy Klobuchar for president, who didn’t come anywhere near winning her own state primary. Or sending columnists like Frank Bruni on TV the morning after the 2016 election to say Dems lost because they were too far left on “boutique issues” like trans rights (https://fair.org/home/nyt-protects-its-pundit-who-dismissed-trans-rights-as-boutique-issue/). That people like him are invited on TV to do political analysis, when he seems to have only shifted from being a restaurant critic to writing political commentary because he developed gout, is absurd.
"Valorizing himself and his co-host Ana Kasparian for 'taking a chance' (by which he means they said things on their podcast), Cenk...." I must say, that one made me do a Christoph Waltz, "Ooh, that's a bingo!"
😂
“Right-wing brothers” - yeah, no. I’d sooner trust a pit viper.
At no point in the last decade have these people given us any reason to trust them.
MTG passed a bill to criminalize doctors treating trans patients. She is a garbage human.
I hate this timeline so much
When did Butch Ware attack PSL? He called out DSA-LA for endorsing a billionaire who apparently made part of his fortune in for-profit prisons. But what (if anything) did he do to PSL?
The video is in here. Butch claimed Peace & Freedom revoked a promise of a gubernatorial position on the left unity slate. And "PSL only gets motion on tik tok."
https://www.joewrote.com/p/butch-ware-the-art-of-leftist-grift
Damn we really are cooked
Jesus Christ is this long. And boring. And incredibly selective of the facts. And filtered through the prism of "What Joe believes".
And in the end a truly bad faith argument which reveals the eternal downfall of "the Left" (wrongfully expanded to include liberals): taking a narrow and unnuanced position on everything and attacking anyone who doesn't hew precisely to that position.
It doesn't even engage honestly with the many reasons BJG and many others are disappointed with AOC. Ugh.
You’re surprised my Substack is “what I believe”?
I dunno if you’ve bothered listening to what Briahna Joy Gray actually says about this, but I think she’s generally been pretty careful (at least when the format affords long-form explanations) about *not* uncritically praising MTG or Tucker Carlson. Her position — the *correct* position as far as I’m concerned — is simply that MTG happens to be doing and saying better on this one issue, right now, than many Democrats including AOC, and that what that should tell us is there’s a wide open lane available for Democrats to run in, AOC and the rest are just choosing not to.
I did listen to it. BJG cut this clip of them saying, "AOC has carried more water for the genocide of Palestinians than MTG." Do you agree with that?
https://www.instagram.com/p/DYfrj3RJFlR/
I can’t say I strongly disagree or see that statement as evidence of malice, derailment, or CIA ops. Telling AOC’s audience (presumably, mostly anti-war and left-leaning people) to support Harris with such a blatant lie is indeed “carrying water” — a *LOT* of water — for an administration that enabled and in many ways actively supported genocide. At a time when, arguably, there *was* still time to convene an abbreviated convention and nominate literally anyone else who’d have had a better chance of beating Trump. A Macy’s Parade float, for instance. It’s difficult to think of a specific example of something MTG did at that level of visibility, at such a critical moment, that did that degree of harm to the cause.
This also still isn’t praise for MTG. It’s very, very sharp criticism for AOC, in that she really should have just *not* said that, but nowhere in that clip does Gray or her guest say that people should go out and support Republicans.
In that same conversation she actually brings up Stephen A. Smith’s remark about getting Black Americans to vote Republican so the Democrats might someday lift a single finger to get them back in the voting base. In order to point out that *under no circumstances* should anybody be voting for Republicans.
The 2024 DNC had no impact on the US government's policy on Palestine. It was either Kamala Harris or Trump. "Carrying water" means supporting. The best time for the left to save Palestinian lives was in October 2023. That was when Zionists were trying to set the media narrative that Palestinians weren't humans.
AOC, Rashida Tlaib, Ilhan Omar, and a few other left-wing politicians tried to stop that by calling for a ceasefire. Marjorie Taylor Greene helped the Zionists by spreading their genocidal propaganda in the US. She specifically began the campaign to call protestors "Hamas" by censoring Tlaib with extremely racist language.
I understand some people felt betrayed by AOC's line. I'm not trying to invalidate their feelings or even change their mind. By pretending that it had more influence on US policy toward Israel than the dehumanization in 2023, which Marjorie Taylor Greene should be tried for along with every other propagandist, is absurd. And it's 100% whitewashing what Greene did.
I’ll concede, for now, that it was probably effectively impossible to get a third party’s nominee into the White House. (This is because everyone always argues it’s impossible, so everyone considers them “unelectable,” which makes it impossible. But fine.)
There was, however, still plenty of time left for the DNC to choose somebody else. Harris was a really terrible choice, there’s no way around that.