18 Comments
User's avatar
Frank Spesia's avatar

Really good point about how active social security users have the highest support for the program. This reminds me of organizers for tenants’ unions. They don’t want the government to nudge the “free market” into building more housing - they want renters’ rights. Good problem solvers focus on the needs of users. It would be pretty cool if our political parties started acting like problem solvers.

Expand full comment
Joe Wrote's avatar

It's such a simple and effective political strategy: What are your needs? Okay, let me help you with those. One cool thing Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum did was establish the beaches as public property. Not because it's life saving, but because its something voters care about.

Expand full comment
Frank Spesia's avatar

Who do you think is doing this best here in the US? Lord knows it’s not from Dem leadership. Who is a bright spot domestically?

Expand full comment
Mary Johnson's avatar

Wonderful, clear article! But what do we do about these people? How do we stop them?

Expand full comment
Joe Wrote's avatar

Thanks, Mary! As for the immediate future, I highly suggest finding an organization that will protest attacks on SS and other programs. Given how popular the program is, I do believe protest and other disruptions could make Trump back down (even if just a little) on his plan to cut it.

Expand full comment
Susan Feiner's avatar

Also, an excellent source for a comprehensive overview of SS is a small free booklet A Young Persons Guide to Social Security.

Expand full comment
Joe Wrote's avatar

I'll check it out, thanks for sharing!

Expand full comment
Susan Feiner's avatar

Joe, your argument is mostly correct. But the Tax Rate for SS is 12.4%, half (6.2%) from worker/half from boss.

Expand full comment
Joe Wrote's avatar

Sorry if that wasn't clear!

Expand full comment
Eli Redman's avatar

I find it hard to believe that only 37% of Americans would be below the poverty line. As someone who is living this if what I have already worked for, paid into the system, and already paid taxes on is removed I face being homeless. And yes, I am working at the same rate that they pay 18 year old's with none of the experience that I have.

Expand full comment
Joe Wrote's avatar

What's crazy is that the poverty rate is less than $15,060. So while 37% would be below that line, far more would be slightly above it. Which is still impoverished but not technically counted by the US.

Expand full comment
Eli Redman's avatar

Yes. It's totally crazy. Really more like completely fucked up.

Expand full comment
Brucker's avatar

Nothing excites right-wingers more than sabotaging a successful government program. They've nearly destroyed the Postal Service.

Expand full comment
Joe Wrote's avatar

It's their only operating feature.

Expand full comment
Fool’s Errand's avatar

It’s always amazing how many young adults love being taxed so boomers can go on two or three vacations a year instead of just one.

Entire society of cuckolds

Expand full comment
Eugine Nier's avatar

Sorry, but Social Security is in fact broken, whether you want to admit it or not.

Expand full comment
Joe Wrote's avatar

Broken how?

Expand full comment
Eugine Nier's avatar

It's basically an unsustainable Ponzi scheme.

Expand full comment