Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Frank Spesia's avatar

Nate Silver just had a long article explaining why Dems would be better off focusing on the economy instead of Garcia, because Trump is more adept at responding to immigration than a tanking economy. Silver ignored that the Garcia case isn’t an immigration issue - it’s a human rights and due process issue. Thanks for connecting the dots to prove that extrajudicial deportation can be divorced from the broad “immigration” category, and that Trump is beatable if people just grow some balls.

Expand full comment
A. L. H.'s avatar

Yay Harvard! (And the law firms fighting back and making progress, there, too.)

I want to acknowledge that the Democrats going down there is action. However, I recently spent some time watching / listening to right-wing media (not by choice) and I’m not sure this is enough.

By so vocally focusing on individual people who have been deported* to El Salvador, Democrats are missing an opportunity to change the narrative about the real issue, which ALL people should care about, and if they were talking about it constantly, there wouldn’t be any confusion on the right about why they want to bring these folks back: hundreds of people were taken from this country without due process.

Otherwise you have the right-wing media chattering about how Democrats want to bring everyone back to release them into the community where you’ll never hear from them again because they love criminals.

It may very well be that some of them should have been deported, and after a hearing, that’s what will happen. Some of them were already in US jails for US crimes, so that’s where they’ll be taken back to. Some of them were legal residents so, yes, after a hearing / once it comes out that their arrest was a mistake they’ll go back to their lives.

But the penalty for deportation was never to be taken to a prison in another country, just like if I am deported from France I don’t expect to end up in a prison in Chile. (At worst, if I commit a crime, I expect I’ll end up in prison in France.)

*Technically, what happened isn’t even deportation. It’s extraordinary rendition, and the media / the Democrats need to start talking about it like it is rather than accepting the MAGA narrative.

Expand full comment
13 more comments...

No posts